Court declares Suswam APC candidate for Benue North-East, voids Udende substitution
A Federal High Court in Abuja ruled that the APC unlawfully replaced former governor Gabriel Suswam with incumbent senator Emmanuel Udende after the May primary.

A Federal High Court in Abuja has declared former Benue State governor Gabriel Suswam the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for the Benue North-East senatorial seat in 2027, ruling that the party’s decision to replace him with incumbent senator Emmanuel Udende was unlawful.
Justice Inyang Ekwo delivered the judgment on Wednesday 18 November, TheNiche and TheNigeriaLawyer reported. Premium Times carried the ruling in its politics roundup on Thursday.
What the case was about
Suswam sued the APC, Udende and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) in suit FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026, according to TheNigeriaLawyer and TheNiche.

He told the court he won the party’s primary on 18 May 2026. The results presented in court gave him 131,083 votes against 1,364 for Udende, Premium Times and TheNiche reported. The party later put Udende forward in his place.
INEC’s lawyer, Anthony Malik (SAN), told the court that the commission’s own documents showed Suswam had won, TheNiche reported. Suswam was represented by Jibrin Okutepa (SAN), while the APC’s counsel asked the court to uphold the party’s objection and throw out the case.
What the judge decided
The judge first rejected objections from the APC and Udende that the dispute was an internal party matter outside the court’s reach. He also dismissed objections on standing and time limits, Lawyard and TheNiche reported.
He held that the substitution breached the Electoral Act, the 1999 Constitution and the APC’s own constitution. INEC’s monitoring report confirmed Suswam’s win, and neither the party nor Udende produced a different result, Lawyard reported.
The judge also faulted the party’s reliance on an appeal committee report dated 18 May, the same day as the primary, saying Suswam was never given a chance to respond. That, he said, denied him a fair hearing.
He ordered the APC to send Suswam’s name to INEC as its candidate and directed INEC to publish it, TheNiche reported.
Reaction
Benue governor Hyacinth Alia welcomed the judgment and urged party members to support Suswam, Premium Times reported.
TIMILEGIT did not find a public reaction from Udende at the time of writing.
Background
Suswam is a former governor of Benue State; Udende currently holds the Benue North-East seat in the Senate. The same judge, Justice Ekwo, on Thursday dismissed a separate challenge to Yahaya Bello’s APC ticket for Kogi Central.
Disputes over party primaries for the 2027 elections are now reaching the courts across several states.
What happens next
Premium Times reported that no appeal or stay of execution had been confirmed by Wednesday night, and INEC had not announced any change to its records. Udende and the APC can still appeal. TIMILEGIT will update this story.


